There were nine students that first term. Jo was the person whose questions I initially mistook for hesitation. She would listen to Mara, try a sequence, then ask where a change began. I privately wanted everyone to move sooner, so I could get through the music I had prepared.
One Friday I gave them an introduction more elaborate than the exercise needed. Jo started, stopped and looked towards the piano. I played on because I assumed continuing would help.
“Could we hear the beginning again?” she asked.
I returned to my own opening flourish.
“The beginning we start on,” she said.
Mara came over and identified the part she meant. We tried it once with a short, agreed introduction. Jo began with the others. Nothing spectacular happened. No one thanked me for a transformation. The class simply continued with one uncertainty removed.
Later I asked Mara whether I had been making things difficult. She said that sometimes she needed less music around the music they were using. It was a precise criticism, not a request that I become an entirely different person.
I wrote “beginning they start on” in my notebook. At home I read it beside the title of a solo piece I wanted to learn. Both belonged on the page. I did not need to discard the solo piece. I needed to stop treating the Friday class as an audience waiting to discover it.
For the next class, I prepared fewer alternatives and asked which one matched the exercise. Preparing less material did not mean arriving less prepared.