Mara returns to the first drawing. Her new caption reads: “P1: grey, elongated pebble, about three centimetres long in this teaching example, with rounded-looking edges and a pale stripe. Given by a neighbour who said it came from decorative gravel. Geological source, composition and age not established.”
It is a longer caption than she wanted. She could shorten it for display, but she keeps the full version beside the notebook drawing. The unknowns are not decorative disclaimers added after a confident story. They determine what the story is allowed to say.
She has not identified a rock type or discovered a mountain range. She has learned to preserve an observation, separate a reported account from something witnessed, distinguish a possible process from a proven route and ask which event an age would describe. Those are real gains within the limits of our invented exercise.
The stone still has its stripe. The light still catches one edge when she turns it. Careful language has not removed either feature. It has removed the obligation to make them prove more than they can.
Mara closes the notebook with the first caption crossed out and the second intact. There is an ending to this small investigation even though some questions remain unanswered: the record now says what she knows, how she knows it and where knowledge stops. The pebble has not surrendered a complete biography. She has stopped writing one on its behalf.
Source notes — consulted 10 November 2026: [USGS, Can you identify my rock or mineral?](https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/can-you-identify-my-rock-or-mineral); [NPS, Weathering](https://www.nps.gov/subjects/erosion/weathering.htm), updated 26 January 2023; [NPS, About erosion](https://www.nps.gov/subjects/erosion/about.htm), updated 12 September 2019; [NPS, How do Square Blocks become Round Rocks on Mount Desert Island?](https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/how-do-square-blocks-become-round-rocks-on-mount-desert-island.htm), updated 29 December 2020; [Mark Stelten, USGS, A beginner's guide to dating (rocks)](https://www.usgs.gov/observatories/yvo/news/a-beginners-guide-dating-rocks), 8 April 2024. These support the stated background, not identification of an actual pebble. The notebook procedure and Mara's completed example are original teaching constructions.