In my eleventh year at the office, Dana bought a ticket carrying a blue case with one pale handle. She asked whether there was time to buy bread before boarding. There was, according to the departure notice in front of us. She went to the shop and returned with a loaf under her arm.
From those two objects I constructed a departure. The case contained all her possessions; the bread was a last comfort from Bellwater. I watched her walk away and felt the familiar mixture of admiration and relief. Somebody was brave enough to go. Somebody else could remain to witness it.
Six weeks later she appeared at the window with the same case.
"Back already?" I said.
She put down the fare and looked at me. "Was I expected to be away longer?"
My face grew hot. I tried to make my question sound practical, which made it worse.
She had been staying with her father, she told me, and was now taking things to a small market on the far bank. That was all she offered. I did not ask what had happened to her father or whether the market would earn her enough. For once I left a life larger than its explanation.
After she had gone, I told Oren, who had recently joined our office, that I had mistaken her for someone starting again.
"She might be," he said. "You still wouldn't know which part."
I disliked his answer for an hour. He had said it while rinsing a cup, without the solemnity I thought my embarrassment deserved. Then I saw that his hands were wet and he had nowhere to put the cup. I took the towel from the rail and gave it to him. The conversation ended there.
I had imagined the window as a place from which I could understand people. It was also a place from which I could see very little. I began to notice how often the stories I attached to passengers made my own position seem necessary: the one who stayed, the one who remembered, the reliable woman beside the bell. None of them had asked me to play that part.